LUBBOCK, TX — In a college football era increasingly defined by Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals, the stakes have never been higher—and the path to success has never been more complex. As Texas Tech ramps up its financial investments in recruiting and retaining elite talent through lucrative NIL packages, a growing number of observers are wondering: will money alone be enough to deliver a Big 12 championship?
At least one Big 12 head coach isn’t convinced.
Speaking under the condition of anonymity, the coach told reporters during Big 12 spring meetings that while Texas Tech’s aggressive NIL approach has “absolutely improved their roster,” it’s far from a guarantee of championship success in 2025.
“They’ve got the money now, no doubt about it,” the coach said. “But buying players isn’t the same thing as building a championship team. Chemistry, coaching, depth, leadership—those don’t come in a checkbook.”
A New Arms Race
Since NIL reform opened the door for college athletes to profit off their likenesses in 2021, schools across the country have been scrambling to build competitive infrastructure. Nowhere has this transformation been more evident than in the Big 12, where mid-tier programs like Texas Tech, TCU, and Kansas State are leveraging booster collectives and corporate sponsorships to close the talent gap with national powerhouses.
The Red Raiders have arguably been the most aggressive. Under the leadership of head coach Joey McGuire and the financial muscle of The Matador Club—a well-organized NIL collective backed by deep-pocketed alumni—Texas Tech has assembled one of the most talent-rich rosters in the conference.
According to On3’s NIL rankings, Texas Tech landed four Top 100 transfers this offseason, outbidding several SEC programs in the process. The crown jewel of their class? Former 5-star quarterback Preston Taylor, who left Florida after just one season amid a wave of coaching turnover. Rumors suggest his NIL deal could be worth upwards of $2 million annually, including endorsements with local Texas brands and nationwide campaigns.
The Joey McGuire Project
McGuire, hired in 2021, has transformed Texas Tech into one of the most buzzed-about programs in college football. Known for his infectious energy, recruiting acumen, and deep ties to Texas high school football, McGuire has leaned heavily into NIL opportunities to accelerate the Red Raiders’ rise.
After an 8–5 season in 2023 and a disappointing 6–6 finish in 2024, McGuire has made it clear that 2025 is the year Texas Tech plans to contend.
“This is our year. We’ve got the talent, we’ve got the staff, and we’ve got the belief,” McGuire told reporters during spring camp. “Lubbock is all in.”
But the anonymous Big 12 coach remains skeptical.
“I’ve coached long enough to know that hype doesn’t win football games,” he said. “You can spend $10 million on NIL, but if those kids don’t mesh, if your O-line breaks down, if you get injuries at the wrong time, it won’t matter.”
Building vs. Buying
This critique echoes a growing tension in college football circles: the difference between building a sustainable culture and buying short-term talent.
For all its promise, Texas Tech’s NIL strategy carries risk. In bringing in high-profile transfers and promising newcomers with big-money deals, McGuire must now manage a locker room with vastly different compensation levels—often a source of internal strife.
“I’ve been on teams where guys are making six figures and others are barely getting meal stipends,” said one former Big 12 player now in the NFL. “That creates tension fast if you’re not winning.”
Beyond chemistry, there’s also the question of continuity. Many of Texas Tech’s new stars—especially Taylor and wide receiver Isaiah Brooks (a $1.2 million transfer from LSU)—are only expected to stay for one season. That places even more pressure on McGuire and his staff to get it right, right away.
“If they don’t win 9 or 10 games this year, that roster’s going to be gutted by 2026,” the anonymous coach warned. “The portal taketh just as fast as it giveth.”
Big 12 Landscape: It’s Crowded at the Top
Even with a stacked roster, Texas Tech faces a crowded field in the Big 12. Kansas State remains consistent under Chris Klieman, who continues to develop elite talent despite less NIL firepower. TCU is reloading after a down year, and new Big 12 entrants like Arizona and Utah have shown they can compete immediately.
Then there’s Oklahoma State. Mike Gundy’s Cowboys remain a perennial threat and bring back a veteran squad that won 10 games last season.
“I’m not saying Tech can’t win it all,” the coach clarified. “But they better be ready for a street fight every Saturday.”
Texas Tech’s 2025 schedule doesn’t do them any favors, either. They face Utah on the road, host Oklahoma State and Kansas State in back-to-back weeks, and close the season with a potentially brutal road trip to Provo against BYU in late November—often a weather-affected game.
Recruiting Revolution
Despite skepticism, there’s no denying that NIL has dramatically improved Texas Tech’s talent pipeline. The 2025 recruiting class is currently ranked 10th nationally—the program’s highest ever—and includes elite prospects from Dallas, Houston, and even out-of-state markets like Georgia and California.
The Red Raiders have also invested heavily in facilities and staff, with a new $250 million football operations center slated to open in August. According to McGuire, the vision is clear: build a championship culture, and make Lubbock a football destination.
“We’re not here to play second fiddle to Texas or Oklahoma anymore,” McGuire said. “We’ve got the tools now to build something special.”
But as the anonymous coach noted, success in college football rarely comes overnight—no matter how deep your wallet is.
The Verdict?
Will Texas Tech’s NIL war chest be enough to bring home a Big 12 title in 2025? It’s certainly possible. They’ve got the quarterback. They’ve got the skill players. They’ve got the momentum. But championship seasons are forged through more than just money—they require resilience, depth, health, and yes, a little luck.
Until McGuire’s squad proves it on the field, doubt will remain.
“They’ll be fun to watch, no question,” the coach said. “But championships aren’t bought. They’re earned.”
Final Thoughts
The NIL era is redefining college football, and Texas Tech stands at the forefront of that revolution. Whether they become a model for others—or a cautionary tale—will depend on how 2025 unfolds. One thing is certain: all eyes in the Big 12 will be on Lubbock this fall.
And for Joey McGuire and the Red Raiders, the margin for error is razor-thin.
Leave a Reply