In a stunning revelation that has sent shockwaves throughout the music industry, the long-time manager of Van Morrison has come forward with a series of unexpected revelations regarding one of the singer-songwriter’s most iconic tracks. The song in question, “Into the Mystic”, long praised for its spiritual depth and emotional resonance, now stands at the center of controversy as unseen tensions, creative disputes, and alleged betrayals come to light.
The Revelation That Shook the Legacy
Last Thursday, during an unannounced podcast interview with UK broadcaster Charlie Lennox, David Griffiths, Van Morrison’s manager for over two decades, shared what he claimed to be “the unspoken truth” behind the 1970 track that appeared on Morrison’s critically acclaimed album Moondance. According to Griffiths, the song’s ethereal composition and poetic lyrics were not solely the work of Van Morrison.
“For years, fans believed ‘Into the Mystic’ was Van’s deeply personal spiritual experience put into song,” Griffiths said during the interview. “But there was someone else involved—a woman named Anna Kincaid.”
The name Anna Kincaid has never been publicly associated with Morrison’s discography. Griffiths described her as a little-known Irish poet whom Morrison allegedly met in Belfast during the late 1960s, a period when Morrison was reportedly battling severe anxiety, writer’s block, and record label pressures.
Who Was Anna Kincaid?
Kincaid, now 79 and living a quiet life in the coastal town of Doolin, County Clare, was contacted by several news outlets following Griffiths’ statement. In a rare televised interview with RTE News, Kincaid admitted to helping Van Morrison craft the lyrics to several tracks in the Moondance era, including “Into the Mystic” and “Brand New Day.”
“I never asked for credit,” she said softly. “It was a gift of friendship and music. Van and I… we were both hurting in our own ways. I gave him words, and he gave them life.”
This revelation immediately sparked a media frenzy, with fans and critics alike questioning the true authorship of Morrison’s work and wondering whether more ghostwriters or collaborators might have remained hidden for decades.
Van Morrison Breaks His Silence
After two days of mounting public speculation, Van Morrison, now 79, released a brief and uncharacteristically emotional statement on social media:
“I’ve always said music is a collective spirit. While the stories behind the songs matter to some, for me, the song itself is what lives on. I will not deny that Anna had an influence on my life and my work, but the recordings are mine. I stand by them.”
However, insiders close to Morrison report that the artist was furious about Griffiths’ decision to go public, calling it a “betrayal of trust.” One source from within Morrison’s label described the tension as “radioactive,” revealing that Morrison is now considering severing ties with his long-time manager and legal representative.
Why Now? The Manager’s Motive
David Griffiths insists that his motives are not about money, fame, or payback. “I’m getting older,” he said. “There are stories that need to be told. Van might never tell them, but they are part of his legacy, whether he likes it or not.”
Critics, however, argue that Griffiths may be attempting to position himself as a gatekeeper of the Morrison mythos, especially as interest in legacy acts continues to rise with the emergence of documentary culture on streaming platforms. Several producers, including teams from Netflix and Sky Arts, have reportedly approached Griffiths since the interview aired, raising eyebrows about the potential monetization of Morrison’s private life.
The Fans Are Divided
Fan communities, particularly on platforms like Reddit and X (formerly Twitter), have exploded with theories, debates, and emotional reactions. While some feel betrayed by the idea that Van Morrison may not have been the sole genius behind his work, others express support for transparency and the collaborative spirit behind musical creation.
“I don’t care if he wrote every word or not,” one fan tweeted. “The music changed my life. That’s all that matters.”
Others are less forgiving. “If ‘Into the Mystic’ wasn’t truly his own words, what else have we been lied to about? This feels like discovering Santa isn’t real, but worse.”
Legal Fallout and Royalty Disputes?
In the wake of the revelations, there is growing speculation about potential legal actions regarding song rights and royalties. According to music industry attorney Lydia Chan, “If Kincaid can provide tangible proof of lyrical contribution—such as early drafts, letters, or tape recordings—she may have a legal claim to partial songwriting credits. That opens the door to decades of unpaid royalties.”
As of now, neither Kincaid nor her family have indicated any intent to pursue financial compensation, but Chan notes that the music industry has seen similar cases before, and most end in quiet settlements rather than public lawsuits.
A Tarnished or Deepened Legacy?
Regardless of the eventual outcomes, one thing is certain: Van Morrison’s legacy is being re-evaluated. Some argue that understanding the fuller context behind “Into the Mystic” only deepens the emotional complexity of the song, while others feel disillusioned by the curtain being pulled back on what they assumed was a deeply personal solo expression.
Professor James Whelan, a cultural historian at Trinity College Dublin, offered a balanced take: “We must remember that even the greatest artists are rarely alone in their process. To strip away the mystique is not necessarily to tarnish it. On the contrary, it might just reveal the shared humanity behind the art.”
What’s Next?
There is now talk of a memoir from Griffiths, tentatively titled Moondance and Shadows, which reportedly goes into greater detail about Morrison’s creative process, his romantic entanglements during the 1970s, and the personal struggles that shaped some of his most beloved tracks.
Meanwhile, fans await a rumored documentary—possibly in collaboration with BBC Music—that would delve into Morrison’s lesser-known collaborators, offering interviews, archival footage, and unreleased demos.
As for Morrison himself, insiders say he has returned to the studio, working on what might be one of his most introspective albums yet—possibly as a way to reclaim his narrative, or perhaps to say goodbye.
Conclusion: A Legend Reconsidered
Whether this chapter of revelations will ultimately elevate or complicate Van Morrison’s enduring reputation remains to be seen. What is clear, however, is that music history is being reshaped in real-time. The unmasking of hidden stories behind classic songs is a powerful reminder that art, like life, is rarely as straightforward as it seems.
And maybe, just maybe, that’s part of the magic.
Leave a Reply