Done Deal: New York Yankees Should Pursue World Series Hero After Gerrit Cole Injury News.

The New York Yankees entered the 2024 season with high expectations, looking to reclaim their place among baseball’s elite and bring home their first World Series title since 2009. However, their championship aspirations took a significant hit when news broke that ace Gerrit Cole is dealing with an elbow injury that could sideline him for an extended period. With their pitching depth now in question, the Yankees must take immediate action to fortify their rotation. One of the best moves they can make is pursuing a proven postseason performer—a World Series hero who can step in and help carry the load.

Gerrit Cole’s Injury and Its Impact on the Yankees

Gerrit Cole has been the anchor of the Yankees’ rotation since signing his record-breaking nine-year, $324 million contract before the 2020 season. The reigning American League Cy Young winner was expected to lead the Bronx Bombers in their quest for a championship, but his recent injury setback has thrown those plans into uncertainty. While the Yankees have not disclosed the full extent of Cole’s injury, any prolonged absence would be a devastating blow.

Without Cole, the Yankees’ rotation consists of Carlos Rodón, Nestor Cortes Jr., Marcus Stroman, Clarke Schmidt, and potentially one of their younger arms, such as Will Warren or Luis Gil. While there is talent in that group, it lacks the dominant presence that Cole provides. Rodón and Cortes are coming off injury-plagued seasons, and Stroman, while solid, has never been a true frontline starter. Given these uncertainties, the Yankees must explore external options to bolster their starting staff.

Why the Yankees Should Target a Proven Postseason Performer

When considering reinforcements, the Yankees should prioritize a pitcher with a track record of success in October. The franchise is built for postseason contention, and if they expect to compete for a championship, they need someone who can handle the pressure of high-stakes baseball. A World Series hero—someone who has delivered in clutch moments before—would be an ideal addition.

Several pitchers fit this mold, including free agents and potential trade candidates. A few names immediately come to mind:

1. Jordan Montgomery

A former Yankee, Jordan Montgomery played a pivotal role in the Texas Rangers’ World Series run in 2023. The left-hander delivered dominant performances in the ALCS and World Series, showcasing his ability to rise to the occasion. Montgomery is currently a free agent and would provide the Yankees with a reliable, battle-tested starter who is already familiar with pitching in the Bronx.

2. Blake Snell

The reigning National League Cy Young winner is still available in free agency. Snell has postseason experience, having led the Tampa Bay Rays to the World Series in 2020 and pitching well for the San Diego Padres in 2022. He is a high-strikeout pitcher who can dominate lineups when he’s on his game. While Snell’s command issues can be a concern, his ability to pitch at an elite level makes him a compelling option.

3. Nathan Eovaldi (Trade Target)

Eovaldi, another former Yankee, was a key figure in the Rangers’ World Series run in 2023, just as he was for the Boston Red Sox in 2018. He has consistently delivered in the postseason, making him an intriguing trade target if the Rangers are open to moving him. His combination of velocity, experience, and big-game mentality would make him an asset to the Yankees’ rotation.

4. Justin Verlander (Trade Target)

If the Yankees are willing to get creative, they could explore a trade for Justin Verlander, a three-time Cy Young winner and two-time World Series champion. Verlander has a history of performing in big moments, and though he’s aging, he still has plenty left in the tank. The Houston Astros may not be eager to trade him to a division rival, but if the Yankees make a compelling offer, it’s worth exploring.

What Would It Take to Land One of These Pitchers?

If the Yankees decide to pursue Montgomery or Snell in free agency, the primary obstacle will be financial. Both pitchers are seeking lucrative multi-year contracts, and while the Yankees have deep pockets, they have been cautious about exceeding the luxury tax threshold. However, with Cole’s health uncertain, the front office may need to loosen the purse strings and invest in a top-tier arm.

On the trade market, acquiring a pitcher like Eovaldi or Verlander would likely require parting with valuable prospects. The Yankees have a strong farm system, featuring names like Jasson Domínguez, Spencer Jones, and Everson Pereira. While they may not want to deal their top prospects, they could put together a package that includes major league-ready talent to entice a trade partner.

The Time to Act Is Now

The Yankees cannot afford to be passive in response to Cole’s injury. Their championship window is open now, and failing to address their rotation concerns could cost them a deep postseason run. Whether they sign a free agent or swing a blockbuster trade, bringing in a proven winner—a World Series hero—would send a strong message that they are still serious contenders.

If Brian Cashman and the Yankees’ front office want to maximize their chances of success in 2024, they must act decisively. A championship-caliber team needs elite pitching, and with their ace potentially sidelined, finding an experienced postseason performer should be their top priority. The Bronx Bombers must

strike now before the season slips away.